Comparison of 3 iPad Note-Taking Apps I've Used
I tried Notability, GoodNotes, and Samsung Notes (which I also use on iPad), using each for two months.
In terms of writing feel, GoodNotes felt the most natural, while Notability was overwhelmingly better for organizing PDFs and managing folders. Samsung Notes' biggest advantage is that it's free, but syncing was a bit unstable on iPad.
The conclusion: if you're willing to pay, go with Notability; if you want something lightweight, go with Samsung Notes. I don't think GoodNotes is worth choosing just for its writing feel.
7 answers
Facts, though — when it comes to writing feel, GoodNotes is the GOAT.
I honestly can't really tell the difference in writing feel. Once you get used to it, they all feel pretty similar... Thanks for the good info.
I've used all three as well, and my conclusion is similar. That said, Notability developed some handwriting lag after an update, so I gave up on it and switched to GoodNotes. It's a shame, because Notability is genuinely far superior for folder management. In the end, it seems like note-taking apps come down to a trade-off between how good the handwriting feel is and how convenient they are to organize, depending on which you use more often.
Well, that's a bit... isn't it a bit hasty to call it a conclusion after using each for two months? The writing feel varies completely from person to person depending on their hand habits, pen nib, and screen protector condition, so asserting that “GoodNotes isn't worth switching to just for its writing feel” seems a bit risky. I'm actually the opposite—I keep using GoodNotes because of its writing feel.
So I wasn't the only one dealing with unstable Samsung Notes sync on iPad. For me, an entire page of notes didn't upload, and when I checked the next day, it had vanished. Since then, I've been backing up to files instead of the cloud. Even if it's free, backing up important notes seems essential.
The fact that Samsung Notes is free is a huge deal lol
Could you be more specific about the sync being unstable? Is it just a subjective impression, or have your notes actually been lost because of a conflict? That seems like a pretty important variable for the conclusion, but it's vague.