Mid-year Review: One Year of Investing 500,000 Won a Month in ETFs
Since around this time last year, I've been putting 500,000 won a month into S&P 500 and Nasdaq ETFs, split between them. I used to only put money in savings deposits, so for the first six months I was just anxious.
One year in, my return is roughly +14%. When it dropped to -8% midway, I really wanted to cut my losses, but what helped most was just trusting the automatic transfer and leaving it alone.
- Automatic transfer on the 25th of every month — not paying attention is the most important thing
- When the exchange rate rises you get an optical illusion in your returns, so don't look only at won-based figures
- Never put in money you might need in a hurry
The conclusion is nothing special. The person who just doesn't touch it wins.
10 answers
It's impressive they didn't cut their losses at -8%. Honestly, if it were me, I'd have completely lost it around that point lol
The one-line conclusion hits the hardest lol. In the end, whoever doesn’t touch it wins.
Never invest money you urgently need — this is really important. I broke that rule and put money in, then suddenly had hospital bills come up, so I cut my losses at -5% and pulled out... Looking back now, it's really a shame.
Good call fixing it on the 25th of each month. I put mine in at the start of the month—wonder if there’s much of a difference.
I was also only doing savings deposits and started something similar earlier this year, and seeing the negative stretch for half a year was really tough. Still, reading your post helps me keep my composure. If you don’t mind my asking, how did you split your allocation between the S&P and Nasdaq?
I don't agree. It's risky to generalize from a one-year backtest that "not touching it wins." Sure, long-term regular investing is statistically superior, but the post doesn't show that evidence. It should probably just be read as the author's personal experience.
A +14% return is pretty good, but given the big exchange-rate effect, the real return may be somewhat lower. For me too, last year the dollar-denominated and KRW-based figures differed by about 3 percentage points.
But isn't this just because last year was a bull market? If it were someone who'd been through a 2–3 year bear market, it'd be convincing, but drawing the conclusion from just one year that "the one who doesn't touch it wins" seems a bit premature.
Is there a source? The +14% would depend on which closing price point it’s based on.
Agreed—automatic transfers are the real answer. I tried doing it manually and gave up after two months, but after switching to automatic, I actually started seeing returns lol.