Two Years of Dollar-Cost Averaging Into ETFs, One Thing I Regret Now
I've had an automatic transfer set up every month and I'm now two years in, and my returns aren't bad. The problem is that I kept switching tickers along the way.
AETF for 6 months, BETF for 8 months, then back to A... Doing that, compounding or whatever—it just hurt my wrist. I think I'd have been better off just sticking with what I picked at first.
Not setting up dividend reinvestment is another small regret.
8 answers
What are A and B? I’m curious what stocks they are.
Well, the problem isn't that you switched stocks—isn't it that you had no criteria for why you picked that one? Without criteria, you'd have kept wavering between A and B. Don't blame the stop-loss; at least write down your buy rationale.
I did something similar for three years, and during the first year I was hopping between things just like you—that’s when my returns were the worst. Now I’ve made it a rule not to touch my automatic-transfer positions at all. Instead, I pick one rebalancing day a year and adjust my allocations. Doing it this way, I don’t have to wreck my wrists anymore.
For dividend reinvestment, just check 'Automatic dividend reinvestment' in your brokerage app settings. However, dividends you've already received can't be reinvested—it only applies starting next quarter. Turn it on now, even if it's a bit late.
Two years in, you haven’t even been through a single cycle yet. The regret you feel now might not seem like a big deal later. Just keeping the automatic transfer going already means you’re halfway there, so don’t beat yourself up too much.
Isn't that old news? These days, the trend isn't just to blindly DCA—it's to look at valuations and adjust your position size. The idea that holding no matter what is always the answer seems a bit risky.
Not setting up dividend reinvestment is a real missed opportunity. Just turning it on makes the compounding effect feel completely different.
Agreed, just sticking with your first pick is the way to go lol