Acquittal

A summary of the concept, effect, retrial, and recent trends of acquittal judgments rendered in criminal trials when a crime is not proven or does not constitute a crime.

Acquittal

Overview

Acquittal (무죄) refers to the outcome of a criminal trial in which the court finds that the facts charged against the defendant have not been sufficiently proven or that no crime is established under the law in the first place. Article 325 of the Korean Criminal Procedure Act provides that “when the case of the accused does not constitute a crime or when there is no proof of the facts constituting the crime, the court shall render a judgment of acquittal,” expressly making acquittal a duty of the court. An acquittal is not merely a finding that the case is “doubtful”; it is a judgment rendered when the prosecutor has failed to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt, and it is a core concept of the criminal justice system as a consequence of the presumption of innocence and the principle of trial by evidence.

Main Content

Two Faces of Acquittal: Substantive and Technical Acquittal

In practice, discussions distinguish cases in which the defendant is found not to have committed the offense at all from cases in which acquittal is rendered because, although the offense may have been possible, the evidence is insufficient. The former is called substantive acquittal, and the latter acquittal due to insufficient evidence or technical acquittal. Legally, both are the same acquittal judgment, but there may be differences in the reasoning stated in the judgment and in how they are treated in substance at later stages such as retrial, criminal compensation, and state compensation.

Presumption of Innocence

Article 27(4) of the Constitution declares that “a criminal defendant is presumed innocent until a conviction becomes final.” This principle applies not only to the trial stage after prosecution but also to the investigation stage, and the burden of proving guilt rests entirely with the prosecutor. Accordingly, the defendant has no duty to actively prove his or her innocence, and the right to remain silent and the right against self-incrimination (Article 12(2) of the Constitution) are also guaranteed. The Supreme Court has repeatedly confirmed its position that proof “to the extent that there is no reasonable doubt” must be the premise for finding guilt.

Safeguards in the Law of Evidence

Institutions that effectively support the presumption of innocence include the exclusionary rule for illegally collected evidence (Article 308-2 of the Criminal Procedure Act), the corroboration requirement for confessions (Article 310), the general exclusion of hearsay evidence (Article 310-2), and the principles of trial-centered proceedings and direct examination. In recent years, issues such as the legality of seizure and search procedures for digital evidence, the admissibility of recorded or video statements, and the scope of exclusion of secondary evidence obtained through unlawful investigation have emerged as issues that determine acquittal decisions.

Effect of an Acquittal Judgment

Once an acquittal judgment becomes final, compensation for detention may be claimed under the Criminal Compensation Act, and a claim for damages based on an illegal act by a public official in the course of duty may also be brought under Article 5 of the State Compensation Act. It also serves as the starting point for remedies such as retrial (Article 420 of the Criminal Procedure Act) against a final conviction, extraordinary appeal, and constitutional complaint. However, because the prosecutor may appeal an acquittal to an appellate court or the Supreme Court, an acquittal does not immediately mean finality.

Retrial and Acquittal

Retrial is an exceptional remedy available when there are statutory grounds, such as when evidence underlying a final judgment was false or when new evidence proving innocence is discovered. Cases such as the Yakchon Ogeori case (약촌오거리 사건), in which fabrication and concealment in the investigation were revealed and acquittal was rendered on retrial, demonstrate the self-correcting capacity of criminal justice while also calling attention to structural problems in the initial investigation. It is consistently pointed out that even after a decision to commence retrial, appeals by the prosecution often prolong legal uncertainty for a long time.

The Reality of a Low Acquittal Rate

Korea’s first-instance acquittal rate is generally known to be below 1%, which, along with the assessment that case screening at the prosecution stage is strong, raises concerns about the hollowing out of trials. Practices such as detention-based investigation, confession-centered investigation, restrictions on defendants’ access to investigation records, and quality disparities in court-appointed defense counsel are cited as factors making proof of innocence difficult.

Recent Trends

In 2024–2025, reform discussions continued regarding the prosecution’s practice of appealing acquittals. Policy tasks under discussion include strengthening the prosecution’s responsibility for analyzing the causes of acquittal and maintaining prosecution, and establishing standards for appealing acquittal cases to higher courts. Discussions on amending the Criminal Procedure Act to revitalize retrial also continued, with guaranteeing the right to request retrial, expanding access to evidence, and improving the promptness of retrial decisions emerging as major issues. On the scientific and technological side, advances in DNA reanalysis, digital forensics, and video analysis techniques are increasing the possibility of proving innocence in old cases, while verification of the reliability of expert appraisal of deepfakes and fabricated evidence has emerged as a new task. Discussions on the possibility of using citizen participation trials and AI-based judgment prediction tools are also spreading from the perspective of transparency and predictability in acquittal decisions.

Related Topics

  • [[무죄추정의 원칙]]
  • [[재심]]
  • [[형사소송법]]
  • [[형사보상]]
  • [[증거재판주의]]