First-Instance Acquittal

A judgment in which the first-instance criminal court acquits the defendant because the prosecutor has not sufficiently proved the charge, etc.; before it becomes final, it may be contested by appeal.

First-Instance Acquittal

Overview

First-instance acquittal (1심 무죄) is a judgment in which the first-instance court in criminal proceedings (a single judge or a collegiate panel of a district court or its branch court) finds that the facts charged have not been proved as a crime and renders a judgment of acquittal for the defendant. The Criminal Procedure Act of the Republic of Korea adopts the principle of presumption of innocence and the principle of evidentiary adjudication, so if the prosecutor fails to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt, the court must acquit. A first-instance acquittal does not become final immediately and may be contested again in the appellate court (second instance) and the final appellate court (third instance) through an appeal by the prosecutor, etc.

Main Content

Concept and Legal Basis

Article 325 of the Criminal Procedure Act provides that when the defendant's case does not constitute a crime or there is no proof of a crime, the court shall render a judgment of acquittal. The presumption of innocence under Article 27(4) of the Constitution, the principle of evidentiary adjudication under Article 307 of the Criminal Procedure Act, and the principle of free evaluation of evidence under Article 308 combine to form the standard for acquittal. The burden of proof rests in principle on the prosecutor, and the defendant has no burden to prove facts favorable to himself or herself.

Types of Reasons for Acquittal

  • No proof of a crime: This is the most typical ground for acquittal, where evidence is insufficient or lacks credibility and the facts charged cannot be found.
  • Not constituting a crime: This applies where the elements of the offense are not met or where illegality or culpability is negated; this corresponds to so-called 'legal acquittal'.
  • Distinction from dismissal of prosecution and bar to prosecution: A judgment dismissing the prosecution or a judgment of bar to prosecution has different effects from an acquittal, and only an acquittal judgment has substantive res judicata effect.

The Korean legal system does not recognize the concept of 'unreasoned acquittal', and an acquittal judgment must always state its reasons.

Flow of Proceedings

The first-instance trial proceeds in the order of the prosecutor's reading of the indictment, examination of the defendant, examination of evidence, statements of opinion by the prosecutor and defense counsel, final statement, and pronouncement of judgment. Upon an acquittal, the court shall, ex officio or upon request of the defendant or defense counsel, decide to revoke detention or release a detained defendant. However, execution of punishment does not begin until the acquittal judgment becomes final.

Proceedings After First-Instance Acquittal

The prosecutor may appeal a first-instance acquittal, and the appellate court, as a court of continued review rather than a court of post-review, reexamines fact-finding and legal application. There are not a few cases in which a first-instance acquittal is reversed to a conviction on appeal, so a first-instance acquittal does not mean a final acquittal. The Supreme Court, as the final appellate court, reviews mainly whether laws and regulations were violated.

Effect of Final Acquittal

Once an acquittal becomes final, a defendant who was detained may claim criminal compensation from the state under the Criminal Compensation Act. A final acquittal judgment may also serve as a ground for a retrial, and if illegal investigation by investigative authorities is at issue, it may lead to a claim for state compensation or disciplinary and criminal liability for the investigators in charge. In terms of publication of judgments and media reporting, the fact of a final acquittal is also used as a basis for restoring reputation.

Statistical Characteristics

The acquittal rate in first-instance criminal trials in the Republic of Korea is generally very low, at around 1–3%, and it is even lower when all cases, including summary order and summary indictment cases, are included. By contrast, the acquittal rate in citizen participation trials (jury trials) tends to be relatively higher than in ordinary trials. Reasons cited for the low acquittal rate include case screening at the prosecution stage, confession-centered investigation practices, and consent to evidence at trial.

Recent Trends

As of 2024–2025, discussions continue on expanding the scope of citizen participation trials and strengthening the practical binding force of jury verdicts, and in the judicial reform trend toward strengthening the principle of trial-centered proceedings and the principle of direct examination, there is a movement to make the reasoning of first-instance acquittal judgments more substantial. In addition, academia and civil society are raising discussions on strengthening the requirements for appeal against acquittal or more strictly reviewing statements of grounds for appeal in order to check the prosecution's abuse of appeals. The accumulation of case law on credibility assessment of digital evidence and standards for evaluating the probative value of scientific investigation results is also becoming an important variable in first-instance acquittal decisions. Furthermore, enhancing the effectiveness of the criminal compensation system and demands for disclosure of the investigation process in cases of final acquittal are emerging as major issues.

Related Topics

  • [[Presumption of Innocence]]
  • [[Principle of Evidentiary Adjudication]]
  • [[Criminal Procedure Act]]
  • [[Appellate Court]]
  • [[Citizen Participation Trial]]
  • [[Criminal Compensation]]
  • [[Prosecutor's Appeal]]
  • [[Trial-Centered Principle]]