Lockout
Overview
A lockout (職場閉鎖) refers to an employer-side industrial action in which the employer refuses to accept the provision of labor by workers during a labor dispute, closing the workplace or excluding workers from work, thereby countering the other party's industrial action. In Korea, Article 2, Subparagraph 6 of the "Trade Union and Labor Relations Adjustment Act" (hereinafter the Trade Union Act) explicitly lists lockout alongside strikes and slowdowns as a type of industrial action, and Article 46 of the same Act adopts a structure that prohibits it in principle while permitting it exceptionally. In other words, a lockout is an employer's countermeasure corresponding to workers' right to collective action, but in order to prevent its abuse, it is recognized only under strict requirements of legitimacy.
Key Details
Concept and Legal Nature
A lockout is formally an instruction or order by the employer under the employment contract, but substantively it is an industrial action with a defensive and responsive character against workers' industrial action. It is therefore distinguished from a suspension of business or halt of operations for mere business reasons or managerial necessity, and a workplace closure unrelated to a labor dispute is difficult to regard as a lockout. In academic theory, there is a confrontation between the view that treats it as an employer's industrial action (the industrial action theory) and the view that treats it as the employer's refusal to accept labor under the employment contract (the refusal-to-accept theory), but since the Trade Union Act stipulates it as an industrial action, its character as an industrial action is recognized.
Basis and Requirements under Korean Law
Article 46, Paragraph 1 of the Trade Union Act provides that "an employer may not, in principle, conduct a lockout to counter workers' industrial action," and Paragraph 2 of the same Article imposes procedural control to the effect that "notwithstanding Paragraph 1, where an employer conducts a lockout, it shall report it to the Labor Relations Commission." Ultimately, for a lockout to be lawful, the following are required: ① the existence of a labor dispute and the ongoing or anticipated industrial action of workers; ② a defensive and responsive necessity for the employer to counter it; ③ appropriateness in timing, scope, and duration; and ④ compliance with procedures such as reporting to the Labor Relations Commission. Case law takes countermeasure character and appropriateness as the core criteria in judging the legitimacy of a lockout, and views a lockout that exceeds the scope necessary in light of the workers' industrial action and reasonable under social convention as unlawful.
Effects
When a lawful lockout takes place, the employer's obligation to pay wages and obligation to accept labor are exempted, while the employment relationship itself continues. In the case of an unlawful lockout, by contrast, the employer is not relieved of the obligation to pay wages, and liability for damages or liability for unfair labor practices may arise. In principle, a period of shutdown due to industrial action is not recognized as a separation from employment constituting grounds for receiving unemployment benefits under employment insurance, and it is generally the case that, under the Labor Standards Act, the period of industrial action is not counted as attendance for purposes such as calculating annual leave. In addition, where a lockout is a legitimate industrial action, civil liability for damages and criminal liability such as obstruction of business may be precluded.
Distinction from Workplace Occupation
A lockout is the employer closing the workplace, whereas a workplace occupation is workers occupying the workplace. A workplace occupation as an industrial action does not give rise to issues of the crime of intrusion upon premises under criminal law to the extent that its legitimacy is recognized, but where workers continue to occupy even after the employer has lawfully carried out a lockout, legitimacy may be lost.
Foreign Legislative Examples
The United States broadly recognizes employer lockouts as a form of industrial action under the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) framework, whereas Germany emphasizes collective bargaining autonomy and mediation procedures and tends to strictly review the requirements for the legitimacy of a lockout. France in principle prohibits lockouts and imposes heavy employer liability for unlawful closures, while Japan recognizes lockouts as legitimate industrial action under its Trade Union Act but requires countermeasure character and appropriateness as requirements under case law.
Recent Trends
The biggest issue in Korean labor law in 2024–2025 is the discussion of amendments to Articles 2 and 3 of the Trade Union Act, known as the so-called "Yellow Envelope Act." The amendment bill contains provisions expanding the concept of the employer to encompass prime contractor–subcontractor relationships and restricting claims for damages and provisional seizures against legitimate industrial action, and thus directly affects the scope of the employer's countermeasures, including lockouts, and the criteria for judging their legitimacy. As the amendment bill, after passing the plenary session of the National Assembly, has continued to face legal uncertainty over its enforcement due to the government's request for reconsideration, a re-vote, and Constitutional Court rulings, both employer organizations and the labor sector are engaged in interpretive disputes over the criteria for the legitimacy of lockouts and strikes. In addition, amid strike situations at large-scale workplaces such as those in the automobile, shipbuilding, and railway industries, lockouts, substitute work, and whether to invoke emergency adjustment rights are repeatedly subject to social controversy, and whether lockouts are recognized as an employer-side response measure against industrial action by platform and specially employed workers is also emerging as a new issue.
Related Topics
- [[Industrial Action]]
- [[Strike]]
- [[Trade Union]]
- [[Collective Bargaining]]
- [[Unfair Labor Practice]]
- [[Trade Union and Labor Relations Adjustment Act]]