My 6-Month Experience with Sleep Supplements (Magnesium, Theanine, etc.)
I had severe insomnia, so I tried all sorts of things. To cut to the conclusion, results vary a lot from person to person, and the one that worked best for me was magnesium glycinate.
- Magnesium glycinate: From about two weeks of taking it, the time it took me to fall asleep was noticeably shorter. Magnesium oxide just gave me diarrhea.
- L-theanine: On days I had caffeine, taking it in the evening made me toss and turn less.
- Melatonin: 1–2 mg worked, but 3 mg or more actually left me feeling less refreshed the next day.
That said, this is just my personal experience, and if you have chronic insomnia, you should go to a hospital. In my case, I ended up going to a sleep clinic while also taking supplements.
4 answers
Agreed, magnesium really is different depending on the type.
Well, I don’t know. They say they felt an effect after taking 1–2 mg of melatonin, but at that dose, isn’t there a pretty good chance it’s a placebo? I agree that for chronic insomnia, the answer is ultimately a hospital, but ending by saying to go to a hospital while talking about supplement effects feels a bit deflating. From the perspective of someone who solved it with supplements, I’m not really sure what the point of the post itself is.
It’s kind of surprising that you started seeing effects from magnesium glycinate after about two weeks. For me, magnesium oxide just gave me a stomachache, and I haven’t tried glycinate yet, so I’m thinking I might give it a try. But how did you actually confirm that the time it takes you to fall asleep got shorter? I think it makes a bit of a difference whether it’s just a subjective feeling or you saw it as numbers in a sleep app or something.
I’ve also been tossing and turning for years and went through almost the same route. I settled on taking magnesium and theanine only on days I have caffeine, and with melatonin, I also get a heavy head the next day if I go over 3 mg. Other people sleep fine on 5 mg, and I wondered if it was just me, so it’s nice to meet a similar case. That said, it’s important to set a dosing schedule for these. At first I took this and that and couldn’t tell what was actually working, which just left me more confused.