A 1-Year Review from Someone Who Started ETF Accumulation Investing for the First Time Last Year (Long)
Early last year, as I hit my third year in the workforce, I decided it was time to start saving money and entered the market. At first I considered individual stocks, but I got scared and started with ETFs instead. Now that a year has passed, here are my takeaways.
1. Recurring investing is genuinely good for your mental health
Rather than watching charts at night trying to time the market, it was much easier to buy on a fixed date every month. My returns weren't bad either.
2. There was a time I almost made a big mistake trying to save on fees
At first, I hunted for low-fee ETFs and bought up anything that overlapped with the index, but in the end the number of holdings grew and management just got more complicated. Now I've narrowed it down to 2–3.
3. You should definitely keep some cash allocation too
When I suddenly needed money, having to touch my investments was extremely stressful. Now I set aside six months' worth of living expenses separately.
The conclusion: starting when I was about to just not do it was the best decision I made. I benefited a lot from the advice of the seniors on the personal finance board. How are you all managing your portfolios?
4 answers
Agreed, especially #3. If you only invest without a cash emergency fund, it really messes with your mental state.
I started similarly too, and it took me a year just to sort out my holdings lol. Now I only go with one core and one satellite. Nice read.
Well, isn't it a bit early to conclude that dollar-cost averaging is good based on just one year? You only feel that way because that period was on an uptrend; the real assessment comes after going through two or three years of a sideways or declining market. You didn't write how much the return was, or whether it was compared against the index, so it feels more like a diary than a review. I do agree with #2, though.
What you’ve learned after a year is pretty textbook. I’m in my fifth year, and I eventually find myself coming back to a streamlined portfolio. At first you try this and that, but after about a year everyone converges on 2–3 holdings lol. And you mentioned fees—adding more holdings just to save a 0.05% annual difference is a real trap. The time spent managing them is more expensive than the money saved. That said, six months of living expenses feels a bit excessive. I get by with three months’ worth plus an overdraft limit, and you can’t ignore the opportunity cost of that money sitting idle. Of course, everyone has different standards for feeling secure, so there’s no single right answer.