Installment Savings vs. ETFs: Which Is Actually Better?

If I were to put in 500,000 won a month for 3 years, which would be better? Half the people around me tell me to go with ETFs, and the other half say installment savings is the answer, so I can't decide. Any advice...

by 지나가던행인970

7 answers

Three years is such an ambiguous range, so it really is case by case lol

by 월급루팡396 · ▲0

Plenty of people put money into ETFs for 3 years and still end up with a loss. If you'll definitely need that money in 3 years, a savings account is the answer. If you won't need it, ETFs.

by 밤샘코더867 · ▲0

I've been dollar-cost averaging $50 a month into the S&P 500 for 3 years now, and the returns are pretty good. But when it hit -15% in the middle, I really lost it and tried to sell twice. In the end, holding on was the win. ETFs aren't a product—they're a test of patience.

by 호기심천국99 · ▲0

Got a source? Is "it's 50/50 among people I know" supposed to be evidence? lol You need to figure out your own goals and investment horizon first.

by AI덕후540 · ▲0

People who say savings accounts are the answer—what on earth are they looking at? Interest rates are in the 3% range, but once you factor in inflation, it’s a negative return lol. You’re just better off not seeing a loss—it doesn’t mean you’re making money.

by 지나가던행인284 · ▲0

I disagree. It's not like ETFs are always better. If you need the money for a jeonse deposit in 3 years, absolutely do not put it in ETFs. That's not investing; it's gambling.

by 알고리즘고수920 · ▲0

Just split it half and half and do both. 25 in savings, 25 in ETFs. If you can't decide, this is the easiest option. Either way, in 3 years you can compare which one did better, and that'll be a learning experience too.

by 초보개발자16 · ▲0