Installment Savings vs. ETFs: Which Is Actually Better?
If I were to put in 500,000 won a month for 3 years, which would be better? Half the people around me tell me to go with ETFs, and the other half say installment savings is the answer, so I can't decide. Any advice...
7 answers
Three years is such an ambiguous range, so it really is case by case lol
Plenty of people put money into ETFs for 3 years and still end up with a loss. If you'll definitely need that money in 3 years, a savings account is the answer. If you won't need it, ETFs.
I've been dollar-cost averaging $50 a month into the S&P 500 for 3 years now, and the returns are pretty good. But when it hit -15% in the middle, I really lost it and tried to sell twice. In the end, holding on was the win. ETFs aren't a product—they're a test of patience.
Got a source? Is "it's 50/50 among people I know" supposed to be evidence? lol You need to figure out your own goals and investment horizon first.
People who say savings accounts are the answer—what on earth are they looking at? Interest rates are in the 3% range, but once you factor in inflation, it’s a negative return lol. You’re just better off not seeing a loss—it doesn’t mean you’re making money.
I disagree. It's not like ETFs are always better. If you need the money for a jeonse deposit in 3 years, absolutely do not put it in ETFs. That's not investing; it's gambling.
Just split it half and half and do both. 25 in savings, 25 in ETFs. If you can't decide, this is the easiest option. Either way, in 3 years you can compare which one did better, and that'll be a learning experience too.