My Takeaways from 3 Years of Dollar-Cost Averaging into ETFs
Since early 2022, I’ve had an automatic transfer set for 500,000 won every month and have been running it for over three years. To get straight to the point: “boring is the answer.”
The first year was genuinely fun. I’d check returns every morning, and whenever things dipped a bit, I’d think, “Is this the opportunity?” and buy more. But after seeing that the extra money I’d bought in like that was instead stuck in negative territory, I felt a real sense of disillusionment.
After that, I just stuck to the rules.
- Automatic transfer on the 25th of every month; no changing the amount
- Additional purchases only when down -10% (to block emotional involvement)
- No single stock exceeding 10% of the total
- Check the account only once per quarter
The last one was the hardest lol. Still, after I started sticking to it, my stress dropped significantly.
After three years, the return is roughly in line with the index. It’s not a spectacular result, but staying steady without wavering in the middle was the biggest gain for me. It feels like we’re getting another correction these days; I plan to stick to the rules again this time.
4 answers
I set up automatic transfers around 2021 too, but I didn’t have a “buy an extra 10% on a -10% drop” rule, so I just left that period alone. In the end, the author probably had less stress. I should set a rule for myself too. The 10% limit per individual stock really seems important—I didn’t follow it, and I completely lost my composure when one stock was down 40%.
Well, if we're talking about roughly a three-year index return, isn't that just the return you'd get by contributing regularly without any rules at all? The fact that what you gained from following the rules wasn't returns but reduced stress ultimately means it hasn't been proven as performance—so this post also reads as little more than 'I felt better.' It would be much more convincing if there were backtests or comparison figures showing that the rules actually produced excess returns over the index, so it's a shame.
Checking my account only once a quarter… that really is the hardest part, right? lol I turned off all my app notifications just to stick to it.
I really agree that boring is the answer. I only learned that after losing for two years trading individual stocks as a hobby. But you should be careful with adding to your position in the -10% range: if you buy at -10%, then when it drops to -20%, you'll want to buy again. I set that line in advance but couldn't stick to 'only buy here,' and in the end it became the same as letting emotions get involved. It'd probably be good to set a maximum amount as well.