Second-Instance Acquittal
Overview
A second-instance acquittal refers to an appellate court (a high court or an appellate division of a district court) reversing the judgment of the first instance (a single judge or panel of a district court) and pronouncing the defendant not guilty in a criminal case in which the first instance rendered a guilty verdict. Because the appellate instance is not a post-appellate review but a continuation of the trial (續審, soksim) and may reexamine both factual findings and legal application, it may reassess the evidentiary relationship recognized at first instance and, if it finds that the crime has not been proven, render an acquittal. This is a natural consequence of the presumption of innocence, the principle of trial based on evidence, and the strict standard of proof requiring proof beyond reasonable doubt under the Criminal Procedure Act.
Key Details
Nature and Scope of Appellate Review
The appellate instance adopts a continuation-of-trial structure that reexamines the propriety of the original judgment, so it may review the entire original judgment ex officio as well as the parts raised as grounds for appeal (Article 364 of the Criminal Procedure Act). However, under the principle of prohibition of disadvantageous alteration, in a case appealed only by the defendant, the appellate court may not impose a heavier sentence than the original; this principle also affects determinations leading to an acquittal. Where the prosecutor appeals, the appellate court may impose a heavier sentence than the original or find the defendant guilty.
Grounds for Acquittal
The substantive grounds for second-instance acquittal are largely divided into: (1) insufficient proof of the criminal facts; (2) lack of admissibility of evidence (exclusion of illegally collected evidence, failure to meet requirements for hearsay evidence); (3) rejection of the credibility of evidence; (4) misapplication of law (denial of the elements of the offense, negation of illegality or culpability); and (5) insufficient specification of the facts charged or issues of distinction from grounds for dismissal of prosecution. In practice, how the credibility of a victim's statement or an accomplice's confession or statement is assessed is often the key issue that divides the conclusions of the first and second instances.
Reversal Judgment and Final Appeal
If the appellate court reverses the original judgment and pronounces an acquittal, that judgment may be appealed to the Supreme Court; if the prosecutor does not appeal or the appeal is dismissed, the acquittal becomes final. Once the acquittal is final, a claim for compensation under the Criminal Compensation Act is possible, and status-related and administrative disadvantages premised on a final guilty judgment are also retrospectively resolved. On the other hand, there are cases in which, after an appellate court makes a reversal and remand for acquittal, the remanded original court again renders a guilty verdict, reflecting a structural characteristic in which judgments are repeated across instances.
Practical Issues
Second-instance acquittals are intertwined with discussions of prosecutorial abuse of appeal, victims' and complainants' trust in the judiciary, and the legality of evidence collection at the investigation stage. In particular, when the doctrine excluding illegally collected evidence is applied strictly, cases emerge in which seizure and search evidence that served as the basis for a guilty verdict at first instance is excluded at second instance and the verdict is reversed to acquittal.
Recent Trends
In 2024–2025, as discussions continued over the practical binding force of citizen participation trials and jury verdicts, the legitimacy of appellate court judgments emerged as a social issue in cases where a first-instance jury's not-guilty verdict was overturned ex officio. In addition, the legality of seizure and search procedures for digital evidence and determinations of the admissibility of communications data and forensic evidence have become major causes of second-instance acquittals, and discussions on revising the Criminal Procedure Act to reduce prosecutors' supplementary investigation and appeal rights are attracting attention as a variable that could affect the structure of appellate review and the effectiveness of prosecutorial appeals. Moreover, as cases in which the conclusions of first and second instances are reversed in large-scale and political cases are reported one after another, the need to establish legal doctrine to reduce judgment disparities across instances, along with the advantages of the continuation-of-trial structure, is being raised steadily.
Related Topics
- [[항소심]]
- [[무죄추정의 원칙]]
- [[형사소송법]]
- [[위법수집증거배제법칙]]
- [[국민참여재판]]