My 2-Year Personal ETF Portfolio Review
Starting at the end of 2022, I put in 500,000 KRW every month, and the current valuation is around 15 million KRW. The return is about 18%. It’s not a huge achievement, but I’m writing it down for the record.
1. U.S. Dividend Growth 40% - I started this to diversify currency risk and Nasdaq volatility. Dividends from this are reinvested into other ETFs.
2. S&P 500 35% - This is the core to just follow the market average. I like it because there’s no need to think about it.
3. India/Japan 15% - I added these as alternatives when China was falling. Performance wasn’t bad, but the returns weren’t large.
4. Gold 10% - For volatility defense. Over the past two years, this surprisingly made me the most money.
My mistake was currency exchange timing. At first, I exchanged only as much as I needed each time, but for amounts over 200,000 KRW, the fees actually got bigger. These days, I exchange a large amount at once and buy individually.
In the end, the most important thing was setting up automatic monthly contributions. I plan to do the same for the next two years.
7 answers
I totally relate to the currency exchange discussion. At first, I also split it into 100,000-won chunks, but the fees ate away at my returns. Now I save up and exchange it all at once, which is much better.
Oh, I didn’t know this—the part about the currency exchange fee.
Got a source? I’m curious whether the valuation and return calculations are correct.
Interesting that you included India and Japan. I was also considering leaving out China, so I’ll take note haha. By the way, you know India ETFs can have big differences in returns depending on whether they’re currency-hedged, right? I’m curious which one you went with.
Agreed, automation is the answer. I did it manually too and gave up after two months lol
An 18% return over two years isn’t bad. But it’s a bit funny-sad that the 10% gold allocation was the best performer. If something you added to hedge against volatility also ends up delivering returns, that means it wasn’t a hedge but just a bet—so for the next cycle, it’d be good to decide in advance how you’ll keep your head together when gold drops 20%. Personally, I think 40% in dividend growth is a bit excessive. Once you factor in taxes and total return, dividend ETFs aren’t much different from the S&P 500, so if you’re weighting them that heavily, I suspect it’s just for peace of mind.
Well, I'm not so sure about that. With an 18% return over two years, considering how much the Nasdaq rose during that period, it effectively failed to beat the index. If you attach justifications like "for currency diversification" or "for volatility defense," isn't that an illusion that makes it look as if there was a strategy behind it? If the structure is 35% core and the remaining 65% in satellites, that's not much different from simply underperforming the market. Since you say it's for the record, we should probably just take it as a record. You'll probably do the same for the next two years, but please make sure to separately note how much dividend growth underperformed the S&P 500 during that time.